Copying the Copycat: Why Kaspi.kz Has Made the FoundryStrat Long-Term Portfolio

There is nothing particularly original about how we found Kaspi.kz.
Mohnish Pabrai (below picture) has made a career out of being what he openly describes as a “shameless cloner”. He’s often borrowing good investment ideas from other investors and then doing the work himself. So, naturally, we decided to copy the copycat.

That is how Kaspi first landed on the radar. But a famous investor owning a stock is not an investment thesis. It is an invitation to do the work. And having spent some time looking at Kaspi, there is enough here to make it a very interesting long-term idea.
What is Kaspi?
Kaspi is effectively a super-app built around three interconnected businesses:
Payments
Marketplace
Fintech
The attraction is that these businesses reinforce each other. Consumers use Kaspi for payments, shopping and financial services. Merchants get access to a large customer base and payment infrastructure. The more activity that moves through the ecosystem, the more valuable the platform becomes.
It is somewhat comparable to businesses such as Grab in South-East Asia which we used on a recent visit and is an excellent 'all in one' consumer tool. Kaspi has developed a particularly dominant position in Kazakhstan. Yes, I did say Kazakhstan. Perhaps not the most obviously hunting ground for a long-term portfolio holding. Their monoplistic position has allowed it to generate very high profitability and substantial free cash flow.
The valuation immediately gets your attention
The shares have been trading at roughly 7–8x earnings. At the same time, Kaspi has historically been growing earnings at a mid-teens type rate and returning a substantial amount of cash to shareholders. The dividend yield has recently been around 9%. You do not normally get a business with strong structural growth, high returns on capital and significant cash generation on a single-digit earnings multiple. Of course, when something looks this cheap there is usually a reason and in Kaspi's case, there are several.
Kaspi is not Mastercard or Visa, and it should not be valued like them. The geography, regulatory backdrop, credit exposure and execution risk are all materially different. The lower multiple exists for a reason. But some of the underlying economics are still worth comparing.
Kaspi has grown revenue at roughly 44% a year since 2020, with net profit compounding at around 33%, while its three-year sales CAGR is still above 45%. Even after the recent margin compression, the business is generating an operating margin of about 40% and an ROE of roughly 47%.
Mastercard, by comparison, is one of the highest-quality payment businesses in the world. Revenue has compounded at around 16.5%, net profit at around 18.5%, with an operating margin of roughly 58% and ROCE above 60%.
So the point is not that Kaspi is “another Mastercard”. It isn’t. The point is that you are still buying a business with very strong growth, high profitability and attractive returns on capital, but at around 7x forward earnings rather than the 25x+ multiple attached to Mastercard. That valuation gap reflects very real risk, but it is also what makes the opportunity interesting.
Kazakhstan
Kaspi's core business is based in Kazakhstan. That brings political, regulatory, currency and geopolitical risks that simply do not exist to the same extent with a US or Western European business. The market therefore deserves to apply some discount but the key question is how large that discount should be. If the core business continues compounding earnings while returning significant cash to shareholders, you do not need Kaspi to rerate dramatically for the investment to work and that is an important part of the thesis. There’s a margin of safety baked into the valuation.
Then comes Turkey
An interesting development is Kaspi's acquisition of Hepsiburada in Turkey. Strategically, it makes sense because Turkey is a much larger market than Kazakhstan, with a large population, significant e-commerce penetration and plenty of scope for Kaspi to export parts of its payments, marketplace and fintech ecosystem.
If it works, the addressable market becomes significantly larger. But it also introduces another layer of risk. Turkey has a history of high inflation, currency weakness and volatile economic policy. Kaspi also needs to prove that the operating model which has worked so well in Kazakhstan can travel.
That is far from guaranteed and for that reason, we don't think the investment case should rely on Turkey succeeding. A useful way of thinking about it is to value Turkey at close to zero initially. If the Kazakhstan business alone can justify today's valuation, then Turkey becomes optionality rather than something we need to underwrite aggressively.
Can it meet the FoundryStrat 20% hurdle?
This is ultimately the important question for us. We are looking for businesses that have a credible route to compounding capital at around 20% per annum over a medium-term period. It’s almost impossible to do this in the longer term, say plus 10 years and very few achieve it. So it's not buy and hold forever, but it's definitely a medium-term target.
Kaspi potentially gets there through a combination of:
Earnings growth
Dividends
Potential multiple expansion
Suppose the underlying business can grow earnings at somewhere around the low-to-mid teens. Add a substantial cash yield on top and suddenly the maths becomes quite interesting even if the valuation multiple barely changes.
In the base case we looked at, assuming roughly 13% local earnings growth, some drag from currency depreciation, continued distributions and an exit valuation around 8x earnings, the return profile came out at roughly 20%+ per annum. You do not need a heroic re-rating. That is what we like about the setup.
But the dividend needs treating carefully
A 9% dividend yield looks extremely attractive, but it should not simply be added to earnings growth and assumed to continue forever. The payout can vary. Kaspi also now has another major use for capital through Turkey. If the company can reinvest at attractive returns, retain enough capital to grow and still return excess cash to shareholders, that is preferable to simply maximising the dividend.
Position Sizing.
This is unlikely ever to become one of the largest positions in the portfolio because of the aforementioned risks. The geopolitical risk alone argues for sensible sizing.
But small positions in asymmetric opportunities can still make a meaningful contribution to long-term returns and that’s where this holding is going to sit.
What to watch
There are a few things that will determine whether this moves from an interesting idea into something more compelling:
Kazakhstan marketplace and payments growth
Credit quality within fintech
Cash generation and shareholder distributions
Currency movements
Progress integrating Hepsiburada
Whether Kaspi can introduce its payments and fintech ecosystem into Turkey
Capital allocation discipline
Turkey in particular will be fascinating. If Kaspi can replicate even part of what it has achieved in Kazakhstan, the current valuation could eventually look extremely cheap. If it cannot, we need the Kazakhstan business to remain strong enough that we have not paid for that success in the first place.

Comments